Religion, morality and knowledge, being necessary to good government and the happiness of mankind, schools and the means of education shall forever be encouraged. — Northwest Ordinance, July 13, 1787

Deplorable Injustice Continues for Lt. Michael Behenna

July 12, 2012   ·   By   ·   8 Comments

Listen to the Christian Patriot Politicast of this column

Install Microsoft Silverlight

Lt Michael Behenna

Lt Michael Behenna

Last Thursday, yet another example of the corrupt attempts at appeasement of our enemies within and without was displayed in the rotten-to-the-core decision by three of a five-judge panel of the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces to uphold the insanely unjust conviction of 1st Lt. Michael Behenna for unpremeditated murder of a known al Qaeda operative who was suspected of orchestrating a bombing that injured and killed members of Lt. Behenna’s platoon.

You may recall this awful story of an American hero Army Ranger caught in the upside-down world of a military machine so compromised by leftist ideology that he became the victim of a gross injustice.  He went to prison for killing an enemy agent during a time of war in a war zone.  This should never happen.

Here is the story, in brief, as reported at the Defend Michael website,

On March 20th, 2009, Army Ranger 1st Lieutenant Michael Behenna was sentenced to 25 years in prison for killing Ali Mansur, a known Al Qaeda operative, while serving in Iraq. Mansur was known to be a member of an Al Qaeda cell operating in the lieutenant’s area of operation, and Army intelligence believed he organized an attack on Lt. Behenna’s platoon in April 2008 which killed two U.S. soldiers and injured two more. Army intelligence ordered the release of Mansur, and Lt. Behenna was ordered to return the terrorist to his home.

During the return of Mansur, Lt. Behenna again questioned the Al Qaeda member for information about other members of the terrorist cell, and financial supporters. During this interrogation, Mansur attacked Lt. Behenna, who killed the terrorist in self-defense. The government subsequently prosecuted Lt. Behenna for premeditated murder.

Not only is this a miscarriage of justice on the behalf of Lt. Behenna, who was acting to prevent further loss of life in his platoon, it is demoralizing to the U.S. troops who continue to fight on behalf of the freedom and security of our nation. Whether it is U.S. border patrol agents, members of the armed forces, or FBI agents, no individual who is serving on the frontlines in the War on Terror should be so blatantly mistreated.

Two wicked things jump out of the initial story.  Why would Army intelligence order this Muslim animal to be released, and further, why would they order that Lt. Behenna, who lost platoon brothers to this barbarian, be the one ordered to take him home?  This was either stunningly bad judgment on the part of Army intelligence or a stunningly pathetic attempt to appease our Islamist enemies.  This Muslim was a known enemy combatant, not some impoverished goat herder mistakenly detained!

The injustice of Lt. Behenna even being charged with a crime continued at his court-martial, as reported at Defend Michael,

•February 23, 2009: 1Lt. Behenna’s trial begins.

•Defense experts testify that Mansur was standing with his arm outstretched when shot.

•On the evening of February 25th, prosecution expert witness Dr. Herbert MacDonell told the prosecution attorneys the only logical explanation for what happened was that Mansur had to be standing, reaching for LT Behenna’s gun when he was shot. This contradicted the prosecution’s theory that Mansur was executed while seated on a rock.

•On February 26th LT Behenna testified that while he was interrogating Mansur he turned his head towards his interpreter, and when he did, Mansur lunged for his gun. The LT fired a controlled pair of shots. This explanation was identical to what Dr. MacDonell told the prosecution team in a private meeting the night before.

•During a recess after 1LT Behenna’s testimony, Dr. MacDonell met with the prosecution team and told them again that the LT’s testimony was exactly what he had demonstrated to Prosecutors the day before and that the LT must be telling the truth. The prosecutors sent Dr. MacDonell home to New York. Leaving the courtroom, Dr. MacDonell told defense counsel he would have made a great witness for LT Behenna.

•The defense counsel asked prosecutors if they [had] any exculpatory evidence about Dr. MacDonell, and the prosecutors denied possession of such evidence.

•In the prosecution’s closing arguments they argued LT Behenna’s testimony that Mansur was reaching for his gun was “impossible” based upon the evidence (despite knowing that their own expert witness had told him it was the only logical explanation.)

•Later that Friday night a military panel of seven officers, none of whom had combat experience, convicted LT Behenna of unpremeditated murder and assault.

This was prosecutorial misconduct of the lowest order.  It appears these people were determined to take down Lt. Behenna, and they were in no way going to let the truth get in their despicable way.

The original 25-year sentence was later reduced to 15, which was little consolation in the face of a completely bogus murder charge and conviction.  Afterward, Lt. Behenna’s defense appealed the verdict on the basis that Lt. Behenna did not receive a fair trial.

This latest case saw the judges on the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces rule 3 to 2 in favor of upholding this senseless conviction.  From the Court’s 56-page decision, linked at Bob McCarty’s website, the conclusion of the dissenting judges states,

A death occurred in the theater of operations. A soldier has been convicted of murder. Was it murder or self-defense? By law, the responsibility for making that factual determination rested with the court-martial panel, not with this Court. The ambiguous, confusing, and incorrect instructions from the military judge deprived Appellant of the right to have a panel of officers make that decision. The military judge compounded that error by failing to take corrective action with respect to the Government’s failure to provide timely disclosure of exculpatory evidence. This Court should reverse the decision of the Court of Criminal Appeals and authorize a rehearing.

Although there were two rational judges on this panel, it was not enough to see that this awful injustice was undone.  This was a hellish and devastating decision against one of America’s Best and Finest.

There is a war against our military, and it has seen a major increase in aggression since the imperious Barack Obama (or whatever his name is) took his dark and lawless throne in our White House.  From massive, debilitating defense budget cuts, to outrageously stupid rules of engagement, to endless wars with no victory sought, to the forced acceptance of blatant homosexuality within the military, our troops are under assault like never before, because the anti-American enemies within our own government, like the “traditional” enemies of America, have set themselves at odds with our fighting men.  This is a sickeningly sad time in our nation.

There is much that could be said here, more than this space allows.  The fact that the leaders of our nation are hell-bent on trying to appease our unappeasable Muslim enemies is a huge obstacle in our prevailing against these blood-thirsty, backward, Islamic savages.  The fact that our leaders have repeatedly taken the side of our Muslim enemies over our own troops is a detestable reality, the remedy of which is to purge our leadership of these turncoat pansies.

In this whole sorry deal, the grace and strength exhibited by Lt. Behenna and his family is remarkable.  In their report on this latest abominable court decision, his family writes,

We will continue to pursue all legal avenues including the Supreme Court, and in search of relief for Michael, we will also contact officials who can understand the perspective of what Soldiers encounter in a war zone and how dealing with terrorists cannot be equated to a drug deal gone bad in America.

Michael and our entire family want to thank all of those supporters who have taken their valuable time and effort to help Michael’s cause and we know that your continued support will lead to Michael’s ultimate release. We will begin a campaign to contact President Obama and presidential candidate Mitt Romney to take notice of Michael’s case and request they use their influence to pardon Michael or reduce his sentence. The people’s voice must be heard in a case where a Soldier faced his enemy in a war zone. Although Michael has told us he was disappointed in the ruling, he remains a man of integrity and character, and will not be broken by this latest setback. He said that when he walks through the doors of Ft. Leavenworth military prison to freedom he will be a much wiser man than when he first went in.

Although it goes without saying, I will say it anyway:  Our prayers for this dear family and this great and precious American warrior are priceless.  We can also make our voices heard as a clarion call to our elected representatives in demanding that they move to undo this terrible injustice.  We can offer valuable money donations to aid in the enormous legal expenses that the Behenna family has, and will continue to incur, in this battle against the giant military-government machine that has unlimited resources at its disposal to resist the Behenna’s attempts to gain the freedom owed to a wrongly convicted American hero.

Note: Reader comments are reviewed before publishing, and only salient comments that add to the topic will be published. Profanity is absolutely not allowed and will be summarily deleted. Spam, copied statements and other material not comprised of the reader’s own opinion will also be deleted.

Similar Posts:

Gina Miller, a native of Texas and current resident of the Mississippi Gulf Coast, is a radio/television voice professional.
Gina Miller
View all articles by Gina Miller
Print Friendly
Clip to Evernote
  • JohnDotKom

    As bad as this one is, it’s not the lone act of lunacy of the upside down Military brass worldview in prosecuting these phony wars. Within a yr or two of the Behenna episode, a platoon of soldiers in Iraq, or Afghanistan (I forget which) was ordered “to go into an Al Quida villiage stronghold, and kill every military age male”. The soldiers followed orders, and more than one of them ended up in Leavenworth prison, in shackles & solitary confinement, but the C/O that ordered the attack escaped all responsibility. I harken back to when/after the Muslamic monster, the butcher of Ft Hood (Maj Hasan) maimed & massacred 40 something “unarmed fellow soldiers”, including a pregnant woman, screaming “Allah hu Akbar”, yet when the P/C media dared to sheepishly ask Military joint chief of staff, Admiral Mullen “Gee, is this an act of Islamic Terrorism?” (ya think!!!???) he replied “I’m just not going to go there”, and of course the Commie in chief, of the same butchery said “Let’s not resh to judgement here”. Instead of the known Moslem, Hasan, being executed (within weeks) under the Military code of Justitce manual (which allows the death penalty for MUCH lessor offenses), the Jihadist Hasan has recieved millions of dollars of health care, and, tax payers are footing the bill for his “defense team” (to which he isn’t even entitled to) to more than half a million already, and his ‘trial’ hasn’t even begun, yet. The Commie in Chief has our military “aiding the enemy”, Muslim Brotherhood, Al Quida, etc, in Eygypt, Lybia, Syria, and elsewhere, re-naming them “the rebels”, to bring about the coming Islamic Calaphate that will soon consume & dominate the middle east, and at least North Africa. All the while, both the would be opposition Repugniccans, and the people’s watchdog, the lying bastard media, are deaf, dumb, & blind to blatanant treason & insanity. My prayers for Lt Behenna continue, but he is by no means the only U/S soldier being persecuted by our upside down Gov’t.

    • WXRGina

      Yes. As I said, there is lots more that could be said here. I did not include any of the Muslim butt-kissing by Obama-lately hosting a terrorist in the White House-or Col. Chessani and his men, or the Ft. Hood animal Hasan or any of a number of other things I could’ve written. I was keeping this about Lt. Behenna, or else the column would never end.

  • Publius Huldah

    The greatest crime a prosecutor can commit is to withhold exculpatory evidence from defense. Didn’t the civilian prosecutor in the Duke University Lacrosse “rape” case get disbarred and go to prison for withholding exculpatory evidence from defense?

    If Romney is elected, let us bombard Romney with requests to pardon this soldier and all other such victims of multiculturalism & PC in the military.

    • WXRGina

      This was reprehensible, Ms. Publius. “They” were determined to take Lt. Behenna down and were willing to hide the truth to do it. The prosecution deserves no better than the Duke D.A.

  • jainphx

    The military justice system is rife with political hacks. I remember one of my hero’s, Oliver North saying that it would take (at that time) cleansing the military of left leaning officers would take 10 years. I would guess it’s worse now..

    • WXRGina

      Oh, man, JA. We may be too far gone to rebuild.

  • retiredday

    Thank you Gina for letting your readers know about Lt. Behenna. I have followed his story and it makes my heart ache, because as it’s already been said, his is just one more story in a pattern of injustice for exemplary members of our armed forces, who were just trying to follow orders. The same type of slime responsible for the unjust treatment of Lt. Behenna called a genuine war hero, Rep. Allan West, guilty of war crimes. Disgusting!

    The federal government has so perverted its war powers, not only do they drag us into unconstitutional wars but those wars are only political ploys designed to line the pockets of designated “good ol’ boys”. They don’t really want to win a war. That would kill the cash cow. They want war to be seen as police actions and they want our armed forces to conduct themselves circumspectly, so as to keep the skirmishes down to a dull roar.

    The rules of engagement certainly aren’t designed for military operations. Because war is so horrible, it should be avoided. But, once we find ourselves at war, we should fight to win. That means devastating and crushing the enemy. No mercy should be shown until the enemy surrenders. But we don’t do that. And in an all-volunteer service, if you take your job of fighting the enemy too seriously, you are bound to get in trouble. Because after all, no one drafted you. You willingly agreed to be a part of waging political wars.

    As a draftee in the Vietnam war, I believe in citizen armies. They keep the commanders honest.

    • WXRGina

      Mike, I wish we would actually quickly finish a war today. There is no reason that we can’t, except the corrupt men running our government and military won’t allow it.

Featured Articles


Charge of the Wimp Brigade

Bob Ellis

A friend sent me an interesting article from Daniel Horowitz at RedState this evening. It paints a painfully vivid picture of the asinine behavior of many "Republicans" who do the work of the Democrat Party by helping advance their policies. He also paints another vivid picture of what I fear we may be about to do here in South Dakota: trade an opportunity for real positive change back toward the principles and values that created the greatest nation on earth...for a feckless nest-feathering politician whose greatest dedication is to maintaining the status quo of cronyism.


Supreme Court vs. Supreme Authority

J. Matt Barber

Marriage is what marriage is, has always been and always will be. Marriage predates civil government. Mankind can no more transmute marriage to something it is not than can we reverse the earth’s rotation or gravitational pull. Despite an evidently contagious delusion to the contrary, not even the United States Supreme Court is capable of overruling the laws of moral and biological physics. Any attempt to do so is illegitimate. It’s moral alchemy.


Civility from Civil Servants

Bob Ellis

Bill Whittle's latest Afterburner discusses civility--civility from our civil servants (well, they used to be servants; now the attitude from government indicates maybe we should call them our "civil overlords"). Is it too much to ask for some civility from our government--the people who have a job in order to serve us, the people--the people who pay their paychecks?


How Illegal Aliens Hurt America’s Senior Citizens

Woodrow Wilcox

Much has been written about the harm that illegal aliens cause to Americans, legal aliens, hospitals, governments, and others in the U.S. In this article, I will explain some of the ways in which the millions of illegal aliens in America hurt America’s senior citizens.

The Israel-Egypt barrier that was built in 2012 (Source: Wikimedia Commons)

Does Your Senator or Congressman Care?

Woodrow Wilcox

A Senator or Congressman who cares as much about America and Americans as an Israeli leader cares about Israel and Israelis will insist on building a border fence first, and then screening illegal aliens to separate the wheat from the chaff. Any Senator or Congressman who does not care about America and Americans will do something else.


Other News

Other Commentary

Featured Blogs

"We don't intend to turn the Republican Party over to the traitors in the battle just ended. We will have no more of those candidates who are pledged to the same goals as our opposition and who seek our support. Turning the party over to the so-called moderates wouldn't make any sense at all." - Ronald Reagan, Nov. 10, 1964