E-Cigarette Ban: Ideology Over Common Sense

A female model demonstrating use of an electronic cigarette. (Photo credit: Michael Dorausch)

A female model demonstrating use of an electronic cigarette. (Photo credit: Michael Dorausch)

E-cigarettes have become a source of consternation for anti-smoking lawmakers who quiver at the very thought of someone lighting up a tobacco product.  This knee-jerk reaction to the dramatic increase in the use of e-cigarettes in public is manifesting itself in places like Los Angeles opting to treating e-cigarettes as if they were tobacco.

The fear of second hand smoke amongst those who have waged a legislative war on tobacco is one of the guiding principles behind these governmental prohibitions with the City of Los Angeles even going so far as to prohibit using e-cigarettes in outdoor public places and parks.

But what is the truth about the vapor emitted from using e-cigarettes?

In order to understand this issue, one needs to understand that e-cigarettes do not involve lighting a paper wrapped tobacco product and pulling the smoke through into your lungs, as is the case with actual cigarettes.

Electronic cigarettes on the other hand are not lit, and are essentially little more than a plastic tube which turns nicotine into a flavored vapor that can be consumed by a user.  The vapor does not contain any of the characteristics of a burning cigarette.  Whereas a cigarette left burning in an ash tray produces a haze that lingers throughout a room or building, the vapor from the e-cigarette doesn’t have the same effect, as it doesn’t emit vapor unless it is being used by a consumer.

When being used, the e-cigarette vapor is only emitted into the atmosphere when the consumer exhales.  The e-cigarette vapor itself has been found to be primarily comprised of nicotine, propylene glycol, glycerin, water and flavors.  This is an important distinction between the vapor exhaled by an e-cigarette user and a tobacco smoker.

Woodrow Wilcox


An internationally peer reviewed study on e-cigarette vapor emissions published in the British Medical Journal’s “Tobacco Control” publication found that none of the estimated 10,000 chemicals found in tobacco smoke, including more than 40 known carcinogens, have been shown to be present at greater than trace levels in e-cigarette vapor.

This means that there are no rational grounds for treating e-cigarette users similarly to cigarette smokers due to second hand smoke fears.   Yet, rationality plays little role with anti-tobacco politicians who insist on placing e-cigarette use in the same category as smoking, leading to some jurisdictions applying cigarette smoking bans from restaurants, office buildings and publicly controlled parks to e-cigarette users.



In spite of evidence to the contrary, ignorance amongst some politicians continues to rein as those who attack e-cigarettes in their war on tobacco are limiting the use of devices that help many smokers lessen or eliminate their tobacco dependency.

The irony that anti-smoking politicians may actually be doing harm to an effective smoking cessation tool cannot be lost on any neutral observer.

Yet, that is exactly what is occurring in many one ideology controlled local Councils where common sense is replaced with a ready, fire, aim mentality that not only misses the mark, but may have the perverse effect of prolonging tobacco use amongst those who they are spending tens of millions of dollars trying to convince to quit.

This article is printed with the permission of the author(s). Opinions expressed herein are the sole responsibility of the article’s author(s), or of the person(s) or organization(s) quoted therein, and do not necessarily represent those of American Clarion or Dakota Voice LLC.

Comment Rules: Please confine comments to salient ones that add to the topic; Profanity is not allowed and will be deleted; Spam, copied statements and other material not comprised of the reader’s own opinion will be deleted.

Rick Manning is the President of Americans for Limited Government and the former Public Affairs Chief of Staff for the U.S. Department of Labor. Americans for Limited Government is dedicated to putting the principles of limited government into action. They work with local groups across the nation to promote freedom, limited government, and the principles of the U.S. Constitution. Their goal is to harness the power of American citizens and grassroots groups in order to put the people back in charge in states across the country.
Rick Manning
View all posts by Rick Manning
Ricks website
  • retiredday

    …not to mention the relative silence hear, when it comes to the greater toxicity of marijuana smoke, compared to tobacco smoke. There’s not a lot of critical thinking happening in the public square.