I do not believe that the Constitution was the offspring of inspiration, but I am as perfectly satisfied that the Union of the United States in its form and adoption is as much the work of a Divine Providence as any of the miracles recorded in the Old and New Testament. — Benjamin Rush, To Elias Boudinot on July 9, 1788. Letters of Benjamin Rush, L. H. Butterfield, ed., (Princeton, NJ: American Philosophical; Society, 1951), Vol. I, p. 475.

Chicago strike tell us answer is school choice

September 15, 2012   ·   By   ·   0 Comments

Banner querying Rahm Emanuel and the Democratic Party, displayed by striking Chicago teachers. (Photo credit: FireDogLake.com)

Banner querying Rahm Emanuel and the Democratic Party, displayed by striking Chicago teachers. (Photo credit: FireDogLake.com)

It says something about today’s public education reality that the two sides in the teachers’ union dispute in Chicago are the union and the mayor.

Allegedly, the point of schools is to educate children. But which side in this dispute has sole interest in children and their parents?

The answer, of course, is neither side.

Unions are about the economic interests of the teachers. The mayor is about his budget and the economic interests of the city.

No one solely represents the interests of the kids.

It’s not to say that the union or the mayor has no interest in the quality of education being delivered. But this is just part of their agenda.

Do union members have to worry that their jobs will be gone if children don’t get the best possible education? No. Does the mayor have to worry that his job will be gone or his career over if children don’t get the best possible education? No.

In private-sector labor disputes, sitting across from the union representative is the representative of a private company. The survival of that firm depends on its ability to serve its customers. Its labor cost is one line item in the cost structure of the products it sells.

The firm negotiating with the union does have to be concerned that union demands will drive it out of business — that it won’t be able to deliver the best, most competitively priced products.

This helps explains why private-sector union membership has dropped dramatically. In the mid-1950s, 36 percent of the private-sector labor force belonged to unions. Today, it is less than 7 percent.

Union demands that cause uncompetitive pricing or poorer quality products threaten the survival of the firm because it cannot serve its customers. The customer is king. If the customer doesn’t like what he’s getting, that customer will go somewhere else.

But what about parents and kids? They have nowhere else to go. In Chicago, they are stuck with whatever outcome the confrontation between the mayor and the union produces because there is no competition.

Beyond this, even the best public school teachers have their hands tied because they cannot provide what so many of these kids need: a structure of values, discipline and a clear sense of meaning and right and wrong.

The New York Times’ Nicholas Kristof writes, “In fairness, it’s true that the main reason inner city schools do poorly isn’t teachers’ unions, but poverty.”

But now we have a chicken-and-egg problem. Are kids not getting educated because they are poor or are they poor because the public schools, generation after generation, provide such poor education in these communities?

Poverty is preponderant among single-parent households, and single-parent households have grown dramatically in black communities over the last half-century. In 1970, 38 percent of black births were to unmarried women. Today, it’s over 70 percent.

Should we consider it an accident that over this same period a cultural transformation took place in this country? Court decisions removed prayer and traditional religious values from our public schools. Is it worth considering that the purge of traditional values from public schools and widespread family breakdown were two sides of the same cultural coin?

I think so. But whether you agree with me or not, parents who want their children in a school teaching traditional values, rather than the moral relativism endemic in K-12 public schools today, should have this choice in an allegedly free country.

Eighty-six percent of the students in Chicago’s public schools are minority kids from low-income families. Teaching of right and wrong is what these kids need. Whatever compromises the unions and the mayor reach won’t matter to them.

What they need is school choice.

Note: Reader comments are reviewed before publishing, and only salient comments that add to the topic will be published. Profanity is absolutely not allowed and will be summarily deleted. Spam, copied statements and other material not comprised of the reader’s own opinion will also be deleted.

Similar Posts:

Star Parker is president of the Coalition on Urban Renewal & Education and author of the new book White Ghetto: How Middle Class America Reflects Inner City Decay. Prior to her involvement in social activism, Star Parker was a single welfare mother in Los Angeles, California. After receiving Christ, Star returned to college, received a BS degree in marketing and launched an urban Christian magazine.
Star Parker
View all articles by Star Parker
Stars website
Print Friendly

If you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a comment below (subject to the comment guidelines listed at the bottom of the article), sharing it to Facebook or Twitter or another social media site, subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader, or have a daily digest of the latest American Clarion articles delivered to your email inbox each morning..

Featured Articles

President Obama on Univision

Obama Fibs Again: When Will the Public Decide Enough is Enough?

Carrie K. Hutchens

As Fast & Furious unfolded, we were told it began with President Bush, but we quickly learned differently. We learned it began under the Obama administration, yet, on Thursday, September 20, 2012, we have the President of the United States falsely claiming the program began under President George W. Bush. Does President Obama think that if he lies with a straight face and says it enough that it will stick and people will begin to believe the lie as the truth and the truth as a lie?

Groucho Marx

A time for truth, not word games

Star Parker

Perhaps now, in the wake of the heat that Mitt Romney is taking over the leaked 4-month-old "47 percent" video, he can better appreciate the position of Todd Akin, the conservative Missouri congressman running for U.S. Senate. Of course Romney's words, recorded behind closed doors at a fundraiser, were not, as he admitted, well chosen. No candidate would call half the electorate deadbeats. But when Missouri Senate candidate Akin used the unfortunate phrase "legitimate rape" in answering a question about his pro-life stand, the leadership of his own party pulled the rug from under him, despite his immediate clarification and apology.

S. Truett Cathy quote in a Chick-fil-A restaurant

Verdict: Chick-fil-A Did Not Cave

Bob Ellis

Earlier this week, liberals started crowing about allegedly having forced Chick-fil-A to cave in on their Christian values, bend to the will of homosexual activists and stop supporting God's values, including authentic marriage. But it turns out that while Chick-fil-A has clarified policies in existence for years, there has been no actual chance in their values or practices. As usual, you can't believe a single word that comes out of these people's mouths.


California Leads-In the Wrong Direction

Rebekah Rast

California has the ninth largest economy in the world. Once booming with private corporations, agriculturally rich farmlands and tourists, the state is now losing businesses, much-needed food crops and even vacationers. How did the state that all other states sought to emulate fall to the bottom? Along with pristine beaches and beautiful weather, California also has a tax base unfriendly to businesses and those with wealth; it has a rampant environmental movement destroying communities and industries and caters to and favors the public sector union workforce so much so you’d think the state was on a mission to commit economic suicide.


The Face of the Left on Marriage

Bob Ellis

This is an enlightening video of young people from the American Society for the Defense of Tradition, Family, and Property. They are out in Minnesota in support of marriage, and they saw some very differing responses to their promotion of marriage. A lot of people honked in support, gave thumbs up and other gestures of encouragement. Others, as you will see, were very vile. It wasn't sufficient for these pro-homosexual Leftists to disagree or give a thumbs-down. No, the defense of marriage by these young people was met with venom, insults, lies, scowls, vulgarity, and more.


Other News

Other Commentary

Featured Blogs

Like American Clarion

Authors (with latest article)

  • Bureaucratic Red Tape Strangles Jobs

"We don't intend to turn the Republican Party over to the traitors in the battle just ended. We will have no more of those candidates who are pledged to the same goals as our opposition and who seek our support. Turning the party over to the so-called moderates wouldn't make any sense at all." - Ronald Reagan, Nov. 10, 1964

NewMedia blog