I had the opportunity recently to join others in spending several hours over the course of a couple of days with Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli, the man who has led the fight among the 27 states that have sued the federal government to protect their people against ObamaCare. I found him to be very likable, an incredibly knowledgeable and capable man who is also a family man concerned about the freedom of his children and his fellow Americans. Cuccinelli is doing a great job for the people of Virginia (and for America), but look for him to only go up from here (he has already announced his gubernatorial candidacy).
This case against ObamaCare has spent the last two years working its way through the appellate court system, winning most of the battles, and has now reached the U.S. Supreme Court. CSPAN recently interviewed Cuccinelli about the case.
The central element of the lawsuit against ObamaCare is the federal government compelling people to purchase a product under the guise of regulating commerce.
The tax argument then came up on the part of ObamaCare defenders once they became worried that the penalties levied in the legislation if you fail to obey the mandate left ObamaCare particularly vulnerable in the courts. They tried to make the argument that the “penalties” (which were clearly unconstitutional) were just a “tax,” which could potentially put the penalty within the realm of constitutionality.
Of 16 judges who have reviewed this case, only one considered this a tax that is within the federal government’s constitutional power of taxation.
Cuccinelli was clear on the stakes: “If we lose this case, federalism is effectively dead.”
Yes, and (though this case is being tried regarding the Commerce Clause) so is the Tenth Amendment, Article 1 Section 8…and basically the heart of America which has always recognized the vital need for limited government to the maintenance of freedom.
He also discusses the upcoming election, and pulls no punches: “This president and his administration are the biggest lawbreakers to run the federal government in our lifetimes.” Indeed, when you consider the way Obama has shown such incredible contempt for the U.S. Constitution–the nation’s highest law–as well as his refusal to enforce our nation’s Defense of Marriage Act, our nation’s immigration law, his violation of the War Powers Act in Libya, as well as other instances of lawlessness, Cuccinelli is absolutely right.
Also discussed was the contraception and abortifacient mandate via ObamaCare, something Cuccinelli calls “Son of Mandate.” He pointed out that a lot of Americans have no problem with contraception, but are strongly opposed to the assault on religious freedom perpetrated by mandating coverage.
In this video from CSPAN, Cuccinelli discusses how some of the Supreme Court justices may be expected to rule on this case, and the elements of the case in general. The whole segment is about 31 minutes long, and Cuccinelli is in the first 26 minutes of it. It is well worth your time to watch if freedom is important to you.
This article is printed with the permission of the author(s). Opinions expressed herein are the sole responsibility of the article’s author(s), or of the person(s) or organization(s) quoted therein, and do not necessarily represent those of American Clarion or Dakota Voice LLC.
Comment Rules: Please confine comments to salient ones that add to the topic; Profanity is not allowed and will be deleted; Spam, copied statements and other material not comprised of the reader’s own opinion will be deleted.
- Ken Cuccinelli at the Values Voter Summit
- ObamaCare Still in the Crosshairs
- SD Attorney General Response to ObamaCare Decision
- Republican Establishment Chose to Lose in Virginia
- SCOTUS to Hear 26-State Challenge to ObamaCare